This week’s Top 5 Wednesday, hosted by the Good Reads group, is: Most Disappointing Reads of 2018. These are books that I read in 2018, not necessarily were published in 2018.
1. My Plain Jane by the Lady Janies
2. Restore Me (Shatter Me #4) by Tahereh Mafi
3. The Date by Louise Jensesn
4. The Isaac Project by Sarah Monzon
5. Paper Ghosts by Julia Heaberlin
Just a girl who writes books reviews and wine recommendations.
from early mornings and late nights
Jesus Loves YOU!
Exploring What Captivates Us
the blurred line between reality and make-believe
Plenty of Books & a Few Bobs!
We are Brenda, Norma and Lindsay and we are The Traveling Sisters. We read and review together. We love to spread the love through our reading groups and our Q & A with authors.
The Good, the Bad, and the ?!??!?!?!?!
What happens under the blankie, doesn't stay under the blankie
What a librarian reads, learns and loves after the doors close
Grab a drink, for this blog is snarky and full of spoilers
Get lost in the magic of books today
"Brighten the world with your Sparkle"
The Book Blog with Illustrations
A Pride and Prejudice Lovers Guide to Other Books
Let's talk reviews, recommendations, all things books
Literary Analysis derived from an Analytical Chemist
Book Blogger
"Never trust anyone who has not brought a book with them." - Lemony Snicket.
Book blog where a passion for both books and food is shared.
reviews, news, and fun on all things bookish
Just a girl lost in the book world
Book Reviews. Blog Tours. Lots Of Book Love.
personal journal excerpts. Featuring Images from the english Country church project.
If It's Not A Rant, It's A Rave
Just a girl and her books
Books, Beauty, Fitness, and Mermaid Hair, oh my!
book reviews and autre media
Because it never stops growing...
Powered by Coffee. Sustained by Good Books
Book Reviews and Other Bookish Amusements
reading. writing. fangirling
a writer and reader
The Book Lagoon
I love books & TV, in no particular order...
the book blog for the comfy reader
Book Reviews and Discussions
I’m sad you didn’t like Paper Ghosts. I went into it thinking I’d hate it and was surprised I loved it! But I can definitely see why people wouldn’t like it…it was really different.
I’m glad you enjoyed it more than I did. It just didn’t work for me. Hopefully her next book will be something closer to Black-Eyed Susans.
I remember really liking “My Lady Jane”, I wonder what made “My Plain Jane” not as good of a read. Thanks for sharing!
I loved My Lady Jane, too. In My Plain Jane I felt like the humor was really forced and not actually very funny and I didn’t like the characters or the Jane Eyre + Ghostbusters mashup. Crossing my fingers the next Jane book is better for me!
I am sad you didn’t like MPJ…
I absolutely loved My Lady Jane, but My Plain Jane just didn’t work for me at all 😦
I guess I’ll be glad I didn’t read any of these. 😉 Sorry you didn’t love them.
Yes, I think you are fine if you never pick them up!
My biggest disappointments were Pride and Prejudice and Mistletoe and Spinning Silver!
Yes, P&P&M was disappointing as a re-telling, for sure. I haven’t read Spinning Silver, but I just read Uprooted and was pretty disappointed in that.
Uprooted is one of my favorite books! I have noticed that while some people do love both, most people seem to strongly favor one over the other, so you might like Spinning Silver!
Good to know! I’ll keep that on my radar then. I think I’ve discovered that YA Fantasy just isn’t really my thing anymore so I think I need to wait until I’m in the right mood to try it.
Did you go into My Plain Jane having enjoyed My Lady Jane? If so, that’s a bit of a bummer that it didn’t live up to the expectation!
Yes, I LOVED My Lady Jane and was expecting to love My Plain Jane just as much. But the humor that I loved in the first book felt really forced in the second – plus I didn’t like the Jane Eyre + Ghostbusters mash-up. It was a very disappointing read for me.
I’m so sorry you didn’t enjoy My Plain Jane! Have you read Jane Eyre? I haven’t and I wondered if that might be part of why I found MPJ enjoyable.
Thanks! Yes, I’ve read Jane Eyre and that probably contributed to the reasons why this one didn’t work for me. I also didn’t like the ghost-busters theme of it either. I’m glad you were able to enjoy it, though!
I can totally see that with the ghostbusters stuff–that was a little out there.
Ah, too bad – but the covers are nice! I read something by Louise Jensen last year, but not that one. Maybe The Perfect Roommate?
This is the only book by Jensen I’ve read. I was really expecting it to be one of my favorite books of the year and was just disappointed!
I read Paper Ghosts, or rather DNF it. I definitely agree with you on that one. Hopefully this year they all will be terrific reads for you!
I should have DNF-ed it. I kept hoping there would be something wonderful or twisty at the end. I hope your year of books this year is great, as well!
Sorry these didn’t work out for you. I hope 2019 is an AWESOME year filled with fantastic reads 🙂
Thanks! The same to you 🙂
I haven’t read Restore Me yet but I’m hoping to pick it up soon! I’m sorry it was a disappointment for you!
I do seem to be in the minority about it, so I hope you enjoy it more than I did! I just felt like it was all rehashed plot and lazy writing until the very end 😬
Ohhhh, a Tahereh Mafi novel making it on this list! That’s quite unfortunate! 😮 Although I never read anything by her, I feel like everyone adores her books! 😮
I don’t think you would care much for her books. There are elements I think you would like (super-hero like abilities), but the romance really overpowers everything else. The first few times I read the original trilogy, I really enjoyed it, but then after reading lots of other books I went back to re-read it and wasn’t as impressed with it. I was still excited for more books, though, and the 4th one really let me down!
Ahhh thanks for the heads up! I do hate when romance overpowers everything else in the long run. It’s definitely not what I signed up for by picking up said book! 😛 Hopefully the next book you pick up by her will be much more worthwhile!
I recently had been hearing a lot about My Plain Jane. I haven’t read it yet though. I only read 5 books in 2018 and I thankfully liked them all. YOU by Caroline Kepnes was my favorite book read of 2018.
YOU was definitely addicting. I think it’s probably one of the most messed up books I’ve ever read, but I still liked it haha. I would recommend My Lady Jane much more than My Plain Jane.
Totally agree with you about YOU, LoL. So messed up, yet I couldn’t stop reading it, LoL. Good to know about the Jane books, Thanks!
Pingback: January 2019 Recap | Stephanie's Book Reviews