Review: The Hiding Place by C.J. Tudor


Review from Goodreads:

The thrilling second novel from the author of The Chalk Man, about a teacher with a hidden agenda who returns to settle scores at a school he once attended, only to uncover a darker secret than he could have imagined.

Joe never wanted to come back to Arnhill. After the way things ended with his old gang–the betrayal, the suicide, the murder–and after what happened when his sister went missing, the last thing he wanted to do was return to his hometown. But Joe doesn’t have a choice. Because judging by what was done to that poor Morton kid, what happened all those years ago to Joe’s sister is happening again. And only Joe knows who is really at fault.

Lying his way into a teaching job at his former high school is the easy part. Facing off with former friends who are none too happy to have him back in town–while avoiding the enemies he’s made in the years since–is tougher. But the hardest part of all will be returning to that abandoned mine where it all went wrong and his life changed forever, and finally confronting the shocking, horrifying truth about Arnhill, his sister, and himself. Because for Joe, the worst moment of his life wasn’t the day his sister went missing.

It was the day she came back.

With the same virtuosic command of character and pacing she displayed in The Chalk Man, CJ Tudor has once again crafted an extraordinary novel that brilliantly blends harrowing psychological suspense, a devilishly puzzling mystery, and enough shocks and thrills to satisfy even the most seasoned reader.

I received a copy of this title via Netgalley. It does not impact my review. 

The Hiding Place will be available February 5, 2019. 

What Worked For Me

-I’m a big fan of Tudor’s writing style. I love the banter, the dark humor, the well-executed multiple timelines. Even though I felt like the pacing was a little too slow for much of the book, I still wanted to keep reading. There’s just something compelling about it.

-Joe. Joe was not exactly a likable character, but I actually liked him a lot. He comes across as an underdog and how can you not root for the underdog? I loved his sense of humor, even it was kind of dark. He’s had a lot of bad things happen in his life and I liked that even though he kept making a lot of bad decisions and was pretty cynical, he still had a sense of hopefulness.

What Didn’t Work For Me

-So, you all know how much I hate it when a surprise supernatural element pops up in a story. I go from reading a believable mystery/thriller to something I can’t take seriously. I honestly think this would work much better marketed as Horror instead of Mystery. I mentally just put it in the Horror category and so it didn’t bother me as much as something like this normally would.

-While there were some surprises at the end of the book, I didn’t really see the point in some of them. It’s hard to explain it without getting spoilery, but I really felt like what happened in Arnhill when Joe was young and why he’s back were the heart of the story, and tacking on an extra reveal at the end that you didn’t even realize you were supposed to be trying to figure out seemed unnecessary.


Overall, I did enjoy The Hiding Place. I liked the writing and the characters – namely Joe. However, the supernatural angle and the unnecessary final twist did sour me a bit. Still, I think fans of Tudor’s previous work will enjoy this one, as well.

Overall Rating (out of 5): 3.5 Stars

22 thoughts on “Review: The Hiding Place by C.J. Tudor

  1. I didn’t know it had a supernatural angle either and it’s a bit of a turn off for me. I’m already happy I didn’t request this one yet.. I still have to read The Chalk Man and was waiting to see what I thought of that one before this one but now I think I’ll give it a miss. Great review though Stephanie!

    • Thank you! I liked this one better than The Chalk Man, but I definitely wasn’t blown away. If I had known about the supernatural angle before going in, I might’ve been ok with it, but I hate when it’s a surprise and I’m still supposed to take it seriously.

  2. I was a huge fan of The Chalk Man, but see a lot of mixed reviews on this one. I haven’t requested it, but keep changing my mind! I may just wait until it is released and I have more time (LOL). I’m glad you did enjoy it though.

  3. I’m sorry it wasn’t a better read for you Stephanie. I don’t mind supernatural elements at all but I do hate twists at the end just for the sake of a twist. I do like Tudor’s writing, though, so I have this one on my TBR list, it just won’t get read any time soon.

  4. Wonderful review Stephanie! I have a feeling I will feel the same as you about the supernatural aspect. Didn’t realize that was part of this book. We shall see! 😊💜

  5. I’ve only read a few books that jump into the supernatural. I think you’re right, I’d rather know that going in! But glad you liked Joe’s character. I often like the characters that aren’t likable. just not in real life!

  6. Sorry to hear about the supernatural angle. Glad that you still managed to enjoy this one, though. And I need to read The Chalk Man. Great review, Stephanie.

  7. Pingback: December 2018 Recap | Stephanie's Book Reviews

  8. Pingback: #BookReview – The Hiding Place – C. J. Tudor (2019) @cjtudor – Nikki's Novel Niche

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.