I read a lot of books that I don’t end up reviewing for whatever reason. Some because I wasn’t impressed. Some because I didn’t have the time. Some I just wasn’t feeling it on whatever particular day I finished. Reviewing the Unreviewed is my monthly post where I share my few thoughts on all the books I didn’t formally review.
The Supervillain and Me (Morriston Superheroes #1) by Danielle Banas. Read November 3-5. 3 Stars.
I wasn’t terribly impressed by this one. I thought the story was a little too drawn out. Very little happened until the last couple chapters. The characters were ok. I thought the mystery of the Iron Phantom’s identity should have been wrapped up sooner. It was written to make you think it was so obviously one person that you knew it couldn’t be that person, so it obviously had to be the other person. And it just took way too long to reveal it. It looks like this is supposed to be a series, but I don’t know if I’m interested enough to pick up the next book when it comes out.
The 100 (The 100 #1) by Kass Morgan. Read November 6-8. 3 Stars.
I kind of just want to write a long, drawn-out list of all the ways this book and the tv show are different. I feel like a bad bookworm for mostly preferring the show. However, if I read this first I might feel differently. But maybe not, because the book really wasn’t anything special. I thought Glass was a completely useless character that could have been eliminated. I understand that she was there to still have a connection to the ship, but honestly I just didn’t care. Let’s be real, though, the reason I read this and will continue to read this series is for some Bellarke shipping that won’t end in frustration.
The Faithful: Heroes of the Old Testament by Priscilla Shirer, Kelly Minter, Beth Moore, Jennifer Rothschild, and Lisa Harper. Read October 11 – November 13. 4 Stars.
This was a different type of devotional than I’ve done before. It’s a 5 week study and each week is from a different person, on a different topic. There is also a video for each week. Each session comes from a more detailed Bible study and sometimes it felt like this was put together just to sell more books. However, there were some really great sessions and lessons that I really needed to hear. Jennifer Rothschild on Hosea and Beth Moore on Esther were my favorites and I will definitely be looking into more from them.
Marriage of Inconvenience (Knitting in the City #7) by Penny Reid. Read November 16-18. 3 Stars.
I think I would’ve enjoyed this a little more if I read the previous books in the series. Though this is one of those series where each book can be read as a standalone, it involves characters from the previous books and they all got a lot of page time. I had a hard time keeping them all straight and other than one or two I didn’t really care about them. I thought the whole marriage of convenience plotline was a little far fetched. We also didn’t get a lot of the cute fake relationship aspects I was expecting. They basically tell their friends the whole story whenever someone asks and everyone else just goes with it right away. The relationship also became real very fast. The book was about 200 pages longer than it needed be. I thought Dan could be pretty crass at times so I never really fell in love with him. However, there were some cute, romantic moments and there were also several humorous moments. I’m giving this an extra star just because I was invested enough to finish it.
*****Book with Future Reviews Scheduled*****
My Lovely Wife by Samantha Downing – 4 Stars
The Hiding Place by C.J. Tudor – 3 Stars
For Better and Worse by Margot Hunt – 2 Stars
I Owe You One by Sophie Kinsella – 4 Stars
Lovestruck by Kate Watson – 3 Stars
14 thoughts on “Reviewing the Unreviewed: November 2018”
I appreciate that you don’t review the books that don’t exactly “do” something for you during the read. To me, I don’t want to spend the time putting down an author (and his/her) works unless I have something positive to go with the negative, or unless the good outweighs the bad. I dislike reading reviews on Amazon or Goodreads that are all negative. Why did the reader stick with the book if it was that bad? That said, also, I’ll review a book on Goodreads that I thoroughly enjoyed and find a review or two by readers who thoroughly disliked the book/characters, etc. Book reading is subjective in many ways, You do a great job on your site!
Thanks! I have written ranty, negative reviews before, but I try to be as fair as possible most of the time. Especially if it’s an ARC, which I feel compelled to finish and review, even if I don’t like it. Or sometimes you think the book will get better and then it does something unforgivable. So I get the purpose for really negative reviews, but unless something infuriates me, then I try to be more level-headed about it haha.
Hi Stephanie – I also think you do a great job reviewing books that you didn’t enjoy. It’s a subjective business reviewing books, but it’s also a given that everyone has different tastes. You give excellent reasons for not liking parts of books and that’s what readers want. I’m also not the kind of person to just put down a book if I don’t like it because I’m always hoping it will get better. And if I spend the time reading it, I want to review it in a fair way. I agree with Pam that Amazon and Goodreads reviewers get carried away when they don’t like a book. I never pay attention to the 1 and 2-star reviews and only read reviews on those sites after I’ve finished a book. The 3-star reviews are the most reliable. It drives me nuts to see so many 5-star reviews out there! How can you distinguish the really great ones if everything is the greatest?
Also, you have a well-defined brand on your blog and that’s why we come to see you! Happy Friday!
Thanks so much! I try to be fair without shying away when I don’t like something. That said, I have given several ranting low-star reviews before. And it also drives me nuts to see all the 5-stars all the time. I STILL haven’t rated a book 5 stars on my blog yet.
I’m pretty stingy with the 5s. They’re usually the classics like Gone With the Wind and To Kill a Mockingbird.
I should have made you start at the beginning of the Knitting in the City series. Sorry. 😦 I’m glad you could still enjoy the book.
P.S. I always love these posts.
Thanks! They’re easier to do than full review posts haha. I’m not really sure if the Knitting in the City series will be for me. I might read the first one and see how it goes (I think the guy in that one was one of the characters I liked).
I would love to hear what you think about it!
I used to watch The 100, I loved Bellamy and Octavia. Haven’t read the books!
I was never really a big fan of The 100 until recently. I watched it kind of sporadically, but I decided to binge it from the beginning when the most recent season was on and now I’m a hopeless Bellarke shipper – which is why I want to read the books. I’m not sure I would actually recommend the books, though…
Pingback: November 2018 Recap | Stephanie's Book Reviews
I was laughing at what you were saying about The 100 (which I haven’t read OR watched) just because I’ve started to realize that I usually end up preferring whichever way I come across first. Like books that I read before I saw the movie, I like the books best, but there are a few where I saw the movie first and then read the book, and end up liking the movie best! So I wonder if we get some kind of weird, subconscious, emotional attachment to the characters the first way that we meet them?? That’s my theory, anyway. 😀 Great reviews!!
I think there’s something to that theory! I hadn’t really thought about it before, but in books with multiple narrators I almost always feel most attached to the first POV we get.
Pingback: 2018 End of Year Survey | Stephanie's Book Reviews